Charcoal was faaar from requested color. They were a Khaki green. I returned them. The blue pairs were defective. Returned those as well. The Ash color was not what i expected. Returned them. I appreciated the free returns label. I kept most of them: 2 black pairs, 2 navy pairs, 3 athletic pairs, 1 white pair, 2 red pair (even though the back seam of one red pair was not sewn together, it had a pretty big hole. My Mom repaired that pair for me). I loved the red color. I think i have enough to last a while. They are a good fit for my body type, long enough for my long legs. 😀